Recent View all
Strategy
Read more
You Built It, But Your Business Members Don’t Know About It

You Built It, But Your Business Members Don’t Know About It

November 19, 2026 0
Featured
Opinion
Read more
Why We’re Fighting to Raise the 1% Investment Cap—And Why You Should Too

Why We’re Fighting to Raise the 1% Investment Cap—And Why You Should Too

November 18, 2026 0
News
Read more
Congress Attempts to Sneak in Credit Card Competition Act to Credit Unions’ Chagrin

Congress Attempts to Sneak in Credit Card Competition Act to Credit Unions’ Chagrin

November 17, 2026 0
Categories
  • Opinion446
  • News415
  • Technology191
  • Strategy179
  • Press170
  • Education122

Trending Articles

You Built It, But Your Business Members Don’t Know About It

Why We’re Fighting to Raise the 1% Investment Cap—And Why You Should Too

Congress Attempts to Sneak in Credit Card Competition Act to Credit Unions’ Chagrin

AI is Already Inside Your Institution but is it Governed?

Anatomy of an Email Account Takeover

Credit Unions Should Use AI to Accelerate Apprenticeship

America’s Credit Unions Announces Keynote Speaker for GAC 2027

What Are You Assembling: Judgment Before the Board Meeting

Crushing Serpents: Understanding Reptile Arguments in Litigation

NCUA Finalizes 11 Rules as Part of its Deregulation Project

A Change at the Top of the Movement

Cooking with CUSO Mag: Crédit Agricole Group and Gougères

Stop Selling, Start Leading

The Rising Tide of Fraud: How Credit Unions Can Fight Back

Why Cash Still Matters in Today’s Economy

Trending

AI is Already Inside Your Institution but is it Governed?

November 12, 2026 0

What Are You Assembling: Judgment Before the Board Meeting

August 13, 2026 0

Crushing Serpents: Understanding Reptile Arguments in Litigation

August 12, 2026 0

A Change at the Top of the Movement

August 10, 2026 0

Why Cash Still Matters in Today’s Economy

August 28, 2024 0
CBX
Main menu
    CUSO Magazine ®
  • Homepage
  • News Sections
    • All recent articles EducationGet to KnowInternet RetailingLendingMarketingNewsOpinionStrategyTechnology
      Strategy
      Read more
      You Built It, But Your Business Members Don’t Know About It

      You Built It, But Your Business Members Don’t Know About It

      November 19, 2026 0
      Featured
      Opinion
      Read more
      Why We’re Fighting to Raise the 1% Investment Cap—And Why You Should Too

      Why We’re Fighting to Raise the 1% Investment Cap—And Why You Should Too

      November 18, 2026 0
      News
      Read more
      Congress Attempts to Sneak in Credit Card Competition Act to Credit Unions’ Chagrin

      Congress Attempts to Sneak in Credit Card Competition Act to Credit Unions’ Chagrin

      November 17, 2026 0
      Data Analytics
      Read more
      Your Members Are Telling You What They Need, But Are You Listening?

      Your Members Are Telling You What They Need, But Are You Listening?

      November 16, 2026 0
      Technology
      Read more
      AI is Already Inside Your Institution but is it Governed?

      AI is Already Inside Your Institution but is it Governed? Hot

      November 12, 2026 0
      Technology
      Read more
      Anatomy of an Email Account Takeover

      Anatomy of an Email Account Takeover

      November 11, 2026 0
      Featured
      Opinion
      Read more
      Why We’re Fighting to Raise the 1% Investment Cap—And Why You Should Too

      Why We’re Fighting to Raise the 1% Investment Cap—And Why You Should Too

      November 18, 2026 0
      Technology
      Read more
      Anatomy of an Email Account Takeover

      Anatomy of an Email Account Takeover

      November 11, 2026 0
      Education
      Read more
      A Terror Tale from the Compliance Crypt

      A Terror Tale from the Compliance Crypt

      October 29, 2026 1
      Technology
      Read more
      Tips for Strengthening Your Audit and Compliance Program

      Tips for Strengthening Your Audit and Compliance Program

      October 26, 2026 0
      Education
      Read more
      Cooking with CUSO Mag: Crédit Agricole Group and Gougères

      Cooking with CUSO Mag: Crédit Agricole Group and Gougères

      August 7, 2026 0
      Get to Know
      Read more
      Helping When it Matters Most: Interview with CUTX CEO Eric Pointer

      Helping When it Matters Most: Interview with CUTX CEO Eric Pointer

      July 30, 2026 0
      Get to Know
      Read more
      Helping When it Matters Most: Interview with CUTX CEO Eric Pointer

      Helping When it Matters Most: Interview with CUTX CEO Eric Pointer

      July 30, 2026 0
      Get to Know
      Read more
      It’s A Wonderful Life: A Credit Union Story

      It’s A Wonderful Life: A Credit Union Story

      July 2, 2026 0
      Marketing
      Read more
      The Storyteller’s Tale: Interview with Storyfi CEO Nick Olexa

      The Storyteller’s Tale: Interview with Storyfi CEO Nick Olexa

      May 21, 2026 0
      Get to Know
      Read more
      A Helping Hand: Bridging the Gap Between Members and Benefits

      A Helping Hand: Bridging the Gap Between Members and Benefits

      May 14, 2026 0
      Get to Know
      Read more
      Advocacy in Action: Interview with America’s Credit Unions’ Scott Simpson

      Advocacy in Action: Interview with America’s Credit Unions’ Scott Simpson

      March 26, 2026 0
      Get to Know
      Read more
      The Collaborative Component: Interview with NACUSO CEO Randy Salser

      The Collaborative Component: Interview with NACUSO CEO Randy Salser

      January 8, 2026 0
      Marketing
      Read more
      Your Credit Union Website is Boring, But That’s Probably Okay

      Your Credit Union Website is Boring, But That’s Probably Okay

      November 11, 2021 1
      Marketing
      Read more
      How Internet Retailing Improves the Communication and Sales Process

      How Internet Retailing Improves the Communication and Sales Process

      July 19, 2021 0
      Technology
      Read more
      Does Your Credit Union Mobile App Hold Up to Scrutiny?

      Does Your Credit Union Mobile App Hold Up to Scrutiny?

      June 11, 2020 0
      Opinion
      Read more
      Improve Your Lead Generation With a Faster Website Part Two

      Improve Your Lead Generation With a Faster Website Part Two

      May 4, 2020 0
      Technology
      Read more
      Improve Your Lead Generation With a Faster Website Part One

      Improve Your Lead Generation With a Faster Website Part One

      April 27, 2020 0
      Internet Retailing
      Read more
      Don’t Let Your Nephew Build Your Website

      Don’t Let Your Nephew Build Your Website

      March 12, 2020 0
      Lending
      Read more
      Frontend or Backend: Satisfying the Masses

      Frontend or Backend: Satisfying the Masses

      October 19, 2026 0
      Lending
      Read more
      Why CUSOs Could Be the Natural Home for the Next Mortgage Innovation

      Why CUSOs Could Be the Natural Home for the Next Mortgage Innovation

      October 14, 2026 0
      Lending
      Read more
      The Case for Reinventing the American Mortgage

      The Case for Reinventing the American Mortgage

      September 24, 2026 0
      Lending
      Read more
      The Return of Leasing: Why Credit Unions Are Rethinking Auto Finance in 2026

      The Return of Leasing: Why Credit Unions Are Rethinking Auto Finance in 2026

      September 23, 2026 0
      Lending
      Read more
      ACH Reserve Costs: the Problem Hiding in Plain Sight

      ACH Reserve Costs: the Problem Hiding in Plain Sight

      May 20, 2026 0
      Lending
      Read more
      The Refinancing Wave: What Credit Unions Stand to Gain

      The Refinancing Wave: What Credit Unions Stand to Gain

      May 13, 2026 0
      Technology
      Read more
      A Machine Is Already Answering Questions About Your Credit Union

      A Machine Is Already Answering Questions About Your Credit Union

      November 9, 2026 0
      Marketing
      Read more
      The Relevance Gap: What Credit Union Marketing Gets Wrong

      The Relevance Gap: What Credit Union Marketing Gets Wrong

      October 28, 2026 0
      Technology
      Read more
      How Much Is Too Much: Finding the Right Amount of Content for Your Website

      How Much Is Too Much: Finding the Right Amount of Content for Your Website

      October 8, 2026 0
      Opinion
      Read more
      Credit Union Terminology Is Scaring Members Away

      Credit Union Terminology Is Scaring Members Away

      September 30, 2026 0
      Technology
      Read more
      AI Marketing: Slop or Solution?

      AI Marketing: Slop or Solution?

      September 3, 2026 0
      Marketing
      Read more
      Brand Consistency: Your Most Powerful Branding Hack Costs You Nothing

      Brand Consistency: Your Most Powerful Branding Hack Costs You Nothing

      August 31, 2026 0
      News
      Read more
      Congress Attempts to Sneak in Credit Card Competition Act to Credit Unions’ Chagrin

      Congress Attempts to Sneak in Credit Card Competition Act to Credit Unions’ Chagrin

      November 17, 2026 0
      News
      Read more
      America’s Credit Unions Renews Efforts Against Credit Card Competition Act

      America’s Credit Unions Renews Efforts Against Credit Card Competition Act

      November 10, 2026 0
      News
      Read more
      NCUA Continues Deregulation Efforts Going with Fourteenth Round Announced

      NCUA Continues Deregulation Efforts Going with Fourteenth Round Announced

      November 3, 2026 0
      News
      Read more
      Court of Appeals Strikes Down Interchange Cap and Demands Fee Limit Rewrite

      Court of Appeals Strikes Down Interchange Cap and Demands Fee Limit Rewrite

      October 27, 2026 0
      News
      Read more
      America’s Credit Unions Announces Keynote Speaker for GAC 2027

      America’s Credit Unions Announces Keynote Speaker for GAC 2027

      October 20, 2026 0
      News
      Read more
      Keeping the Signal Steady: Celebrating International Credit Union Day 2026

      Keeping the Signal Steady: Celebrating International Credit Union Day 2026

      October 15, 2026 0
      Strategy
      Read more
      You Built It, But Your Business Members Don’t Know About It

      You Built It, But Your Business Members Don’t Know About It

      November 19, 2026 0
      Featured
      Opinion
      Read more
      Why We’re Fighting to Raise the 1% Investment Cap—And Why You Should Too

      Why We’re Fighting to Raise the 1% Investment Cap—And Why You Should Too

      November 18, 2026 0
      Opinion
      Read more
      Credit Unions: Some “Kind” of Wonderful

      Credit Unions: Some “Kind” of Wonderful

      November 2, 2026 0
      Opinion
      Read more
      Credit Union Terminology Is Scaring Members Away

      Credit Union Terminology Is Scaring Members Away

      September 30, 2026 0
      Opinion
      Read more
      How to Hire the Perfect Employee

      How to Hire the Perfect Employee

      September 28, 2026 0
      Technology
      Read more
      Swipe Left or Right: Spotting Vendor Red Flags

      Swipe Left or Right: Spotting Vendor Red Flags

      September 9, 2026 0
      Strategy
      Read more
      You Built It, But Your Business Members Don’t Know About It

      You Built It, But Your Business Members Don’t Know About It

      November 19, 2026 0
      Strategy
      Read more
      The Smaug Conundrum: Are Credit Unions Sitting on the Key to Growth?

      The Smaug Conundrum: Are Credit Unions Sitting on the Key to Growth?

      November 5, 2026 0
      Technology
      Read more
      AI and Cybersecurity for Credit Unions: Helpful Tool, Attack Multiplier, and a Whole Lotta Hype

      AI and Cybersecurity for Credit Unions: Helpful Tool, Attack Multiplier, and a Whole Lotta Hype

      October 22, 2026 0
      Strategy
      Read more
      How Did We Get Here: Navigating the Alignment Gap

      How Did We Get Here: Navigating the Alignment Gap

      October 7, 2026 0
      Strategy
      Read more
      Investing In Your “Perfect Hire”

      Investing In Your “Perfect Hire”

      October 5, 2026 0
      Strategy
      Read more
      Credit Unions Are Missing a Golden Opportunity and Most Don’t Know It

      Credit Unions Are Missing a Golden Opportunity and Most Don’t Know It

      September 21, 2026 0
      Technology
      Read more
      AI is Already Inside Your Institution but is it Governed?

      AI is Already Inside Your Institution but is it Governed? Hot

      November 12, 2026 0
      Technology
      Read more
      Anatomy of an Email Account Takeover

      Anatomy of an Email Account Takeover

      November 11, 2026 0
      Technology
      Read more
      A Machine Is Already Answering Questions About Your Credit Union

      A Machine Is Already Answering Questions About Your Credit Union

      November 9, 2026 0
      Technology
      Read more
      Credit Unions Should Use AI to Accelerate Apprenticeship

      Credit Unions Should Use AI to Accelerate Apprenticeship

      November 4, 2026 0
      Technology
      Read more
      Tips for Strengthening Your Audit and Compliance Program

      Tips for Strengthening Your Audit and Compliance Program

      October 26, 2026 0
      Technology
      Read more
      AI and Cybersecurity for Credit Unions: Helpful Tool, Attack Multiplier, and a Whole Lotta Hype

      AI and Cybersecurity for Credit Unions: Helpful Tool, Attack Multiplier, and a Whole Lotta Hype

      October 22, 2026 0
      View all
  • Subscribe
  • Submit a Story!
  • Advertise With Us
  • Press Center
  • About
    • Contact us
Lipstick on a Pig: What Credit Unions Can Learn from the Cracker Barrel Rebrand Mess
Marketing

Lipstick on a Pig: What Credit Unions Can Learn from the Cracker Barrel Rebrand Mess

September 15, 2025 0
498 views
Like
Dislike
0 0

This article first appeared on YourMarketing.Co.

Cracker Barrel made headlines recently when it tried to “modernize” its brand. Out went Uncle Herschel leaning on the barrel. In came a slick, simplified logo that no one asked for. The reaction? Well, let’s just say it didn’t go well. Customers revolted, social media lit up, stock value dropped, and within a week, Cracker Barrel quietly put Herschel back where he belonged.

So what happened? Pretty simple: they thought a new look would fix deeper issues. It didn’t. Because a brand isn’t your logo, it is what people experience when they interact with you. And credit unions should pay attention here to avoid following in Cracker Barrel’s footsteps.

The lipstick on a pig problem

Too many credit unions rebrand for one reason: they think a new logo or name will suddenly make them relevant. It’s an easier conversation than fixing long wait times, a clunky digital experience, or a culture that’s grown stale. But here’s the truth—if you’ve got operational or cultural issues holding you back, no amount of design work is going to solve that.

You can’t out-design disengaged staff.
You can’t out-logo poor member service.
You can’t rebrand your way out of irrelevance.

Cracker Barrel is a cautionary tale

Cracker Barrel didn’t lose customers because of a logo. They lost customers’ trust because they underestimated what their customers valued. They thought a fresh coat of paint would be enough. Turns out, it wasn’t just about the look—it was about the connection.

Credit unions do the same thing when they decide to change their logo, name, or tagline without fixing the real stuff first. If members don’t feel heard, if your systems frustrate them, if your staff is burned out—a new brand won’t magically change that. In fact, it can make the problem worse.

Do this instead

If you want your brand to matter, tackle issues in the following order:

  • Start with members. Ask what they need, what they value, and what frustrates them.
  • Fix what’s broken. Operations, culture, systems—deal with the hard stuff first.
  • Then evolve the look. Once the foundation is strong, the visuals can follow.

The Bottom Line

Your brand is not your logo. It’s not your color palette. It’s not the name on the building. Your brand is what members say about you when you’re not in the room.Cracker Barrel learned that the hard way. Credit unions don’t need to.

Author

  • Bo McDonald

    CEO/President, Your Marketing Co

    View all posts
brand7 branding16 logo1 marketing101
Previous
Education
Read more
Igniting a Financial Rebellion: Modernizing Financial Literacy for Younger Generations

Igniting a Financial Rebellion: Modernizing Financial Literacy for Younger Generations

Next
Marketing
Read more
The Tips and Tricks of Building a Banner

The Tips and Tricks of Building a Banner

Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sign Up For Our Weekly Newsletter

Subscribe

* indicates required

CBX
Press Releases View all
Press
Read more
Members of Tennessee and Mississippi Credit Union Trade Associations Overwhelmingly Vote to Merge

Members of Tennessee and Mississippi Credit Union Trade Associations Overwhelmingly Vote to Merge

December 17, 2025 0
Press
Read more
Michigan Legacy Credit Union Receives Community Impact Award

Michigan Legacy Credit Union Receives Community Impact Award

November 10, 2025 0
Press
Read more
1st Community FCU CEO Bill Nikolauk appointed to CU*Answers Board of Directors

1st Community FCU CEO Bill Nikolauk appointed to CU*Answers Board of Directors

October 29, 2025 0
Press
Read more
Neighbors Federal Credit Union Names Jody Caraccioli as Next President/CEO

Neighbors Federal Credit Union Names Jody Caraccioli as Next President/CEO

August 21, 2025 0
Press
Read more
MSUFCU Puts Its Mission into Action, Uniting Community and Commerce at Signature Events

MSUFCU Puts Its Mission into Action, Uniting Community and Commerce at Signature Events

August 21, 2025 0
Press
Read more
GTE Financial Named One of American Banker’s Best Credit Unions to Work For in 2025

GTE Financial Named One of American Banker’s Best Credit Unions to Work For in 2025

August 20, 2025 0
Recent posts View all
Strategy
Read more
You Built It, But Your Business Members Don’t Know About It

You Built It, But Your Business Members Don’t Know About It

November 19, 2026 0
Featured
Opinion
Read more
Why We’re Fighting to Raise the 1% Investment Cap—And Why You Should Too

Why We’re Fighting to Raise the 1% Investment Cap—And Why You Should Too

November 18, 2026 0
News
Read more
Congress Attempts to Sneak in Credit Card Competition Act to Credit Unions’ Chagrin

Congress Attempts to Sneak in Credit Card Competition Act to Credit Unions’ Chagrin

November 17, 2026 0
Data Analytics
Read more
Your Members Are Telling You What They Need, But Are You Listening?

Your Members Are Telling You What They Need, But Are You Listening?

November 16, 2026 0
Technology
Read more
AI is Already Inside Your Institution but is it Governed?

AI is Already Inside Your Institution but is it Governed? Hot

November 12, 2026 0
Technology
Read more
Anatomy of an Email Account Takeover

Anatomy of an Email Account Takeover

November 11, 2026 0
Tags
NCUA274press release145credit unions119marketing101technology85leadership84mergers73cybersecurity72CUNA71America's Credit Unions69lending65member service65opinion63AI61WashingtonCUDaily58CFPB54cooperatives51artificial intelligence50financial literacy49legislation47
CUSO Magazine ®

News from the cuasterisk.com network

CUSO Magazine delivers relevant, timely news and insights to the credit union industry. CUSO Magazine begins as a digital product with the potential to grow.

CUSO Magazine approaches stories with the mindset that we want to bring something new with our information and create a sense of intrigue for the reader to want to learn more.

If you have a story idea, would like to submit an article, or want to advertise with us, please contact us.

Recents posts View all
Strategy
Read more
You Built It, But Your Business Members Don’t Know About It

You Built It, But Your Business Members Don’t Know About It

November 19, 2026 0
Featured
Opinion
Read more
Why We’re Fighting to Raise the 1% Investment Cap—And Why You Should Too

Why We’re Fighting to Raise the 1% Investment Cap—And Why You Should Too

November 18, 2026 0
News
Read more
Congress Attempts to Sneak in Credit Card Competition Act to Credit Unions’ Chagrin

Congress Attempts to Sneak in Credit Card Competition Act to Credit Unions’ Chagrin

November 17, 2026 0
Data Analytics
Read more
Your Members Are Telling You What They Need, But Are You Listening?

Your Members Are Telling You What They Need, But Are You Listening?

November 16, 2026 0
Categories
  • Opinion446
  • News415
  • Technology191
  • Strategy179
  • Press170
  • Education122
  • Marketing102
  • Leadership78
  • Data Analytics63
  • Lending47
  • Get to Know35
  • Internet Retailing20
  • Sponsored3
  • Uncategorized3
CUSO Magazine Tweets
Tweets by cusomag
© 2024 CU*Answers. All Rights Reserved. CUSO Magazine ® is a registered trademark of CU*Answers. Privacy