How do you get a piece of controversial legislation passed? Sneak it in with completely unrelated legislation and hope it goes unnoticed. Senators have made another attempt to pass the Credit Card Competition Act (CCCA), this time by attaching it as an amendment to the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act. The CCCA largely benefits retailers, and is this is the latest attempt to get the Act passed by attaching it to popular legislation packages in the closing weeks of this congressional session.
America’s Credit Unions was quick to notice and respond to these latest attempts, issuing a letter to Senate leadership this week, offering their warnings of the legislation and how it will affect credit unions and consumers. In the letter, ACU warns that mandates like those included in the CCCA do not lead to lower prices for consumers as implied, instead resulting in handouts to retailers. Per the ACU, previous attempts like with the debit routing requirements issued with the Dodd-Frank Act’s 2010 Durbin Amendment resulted in less than 2 percent of merchants reducing prices, versus 20 percent actually raising prices. By repeating these measures, but this time with credit cards, ACU suggests Congress and consumers will be able to expect more of the same.
What’s more, by allowing retailers to choose what network to use when processing transactions, they may have turned to cheaper, less secure options, bypassing the consumer’s choice when picking a debit card or now a credit card. And the ones left holding the bag for the higher rates of plastic fraud are the credit unions, not the retailers. Faced with reduced revenue and higher costs, credit unions may have to “tighten credit standards or stop issuing credit cards altogether. Consumers with less–than–perfect credit or no credit have greater access to secure financial services due to, in large part, the funding and benefits provided by the current interchange system.”
Despite the concerns about the CCCA’s inclusion in the other legislation, ACU does not seem overly concerned that it will work. “The amendment faces long odds as Congress races to complete a packed year-end agenda that includes government funding and other high-priority legislative items before adjournment. America’s Credit Unions’ Advocacy Team does not anticipate the effort to gain traction before the end of the session, as the legislation in question is already a heavily negotiated package.


























































