13 views
0

Since their inception, credit unions have championed the cooperative model and the belief that we are stronger together.

Credit Union Service Organizations (CUSOs) are that belief in action. When credit unions come together through a CUSO, they share resources, expertise, and risk, and build a scale few could reach on their own. Some of the most successful CUSOs now serve thousands of financial institutions, such as Origence for indirect lending, Velera for technology solutions and payment processing, and MBFS for Commercial and Member Business Lending.

But the framework governing how credit unions invest in CUSOs was built for an incredibly different era, and it hasn’t kept up with the rapidly changing financial services landscape. One provision in particular is holding our movement back: the 1% investment cap.

What is the 1% investment cap?

Federal credit unions can invest in organizations that support credit union operations, including CUSOs, but their total investment is capped at just 1% of their paid-in and unimpaired capital and surplus—essentially, their shares plus undivided earnings. That’s a combined limit across every CUSO investment a credit union makes. And because the cap is written into the Federal Credit Union Act rather than NCUA regulation, raising or eliminating it literally requires an act of Congress.

That credit union might have investments in a commercial lending CUSO, a mortgage services organization, an insurance-related CUSO, and a technology provider. Every dollar counts toward the same limit. Once the credit union reaches its cap, it cannot invest in another CUSO, no matter how strong its balance sheet or how compelling the opportunity.

The irony is that the credit unions most committed to collaboration are the first to hit the wall. As former NCUA Chairman Dennis Dollar has pointed out, the most progressive credit unions are the ones that have already invested in multiple CUSOs, which leaves them the least room for the AI and FinTech CUSOs they need next.

There is a separate 1% limit for loans to CUSOs, which provides some flexibility and support. But a loan isn’t the same as an equity investment, and it doesn’t help credit unions that want an ownership stake and a seat at the table in a CUSO.

Note, too, that the 1% cap applies to federal credit unions. State-chartered credit unions must follow varying state laws, many of which allow higher limits. That adds another layer of complexity and creates unequal investment opportunities for credit unions based solely on their charter.

Where did the 1% cap come from?

Congress set the 1% limit in 1977, when it amended the Federal Credit Union Act to let federal credit unions invest in organizations serving credit union operations.

Think about what the financial services industry looked like in 1977 (for those of you who were around to remember it). The internet, smartphones, home banking, digital payments, mobile apps, cloud services, artificial intelligence, cryptocurrency, data analytics, modern fraud prevention, and so much more have emerged and evolved over the nearly 50 years since.

Yet the 1% cap remains the same.

What’s more, there’s no documented explanation for why 1% was chosen in the first place. As our General Counsel Brian Lauer explained in an interview with CU Today, the legislative history contains no discussion of the number at all. It is, simply, arbitrary.

Mind the innovation gap

Raising the 1% cap becomes even more urgent given the technology advancements happening right now.

From AI and stablecoins to digital payments and other emerging technologies, credit unions have more opportunities than ever to improve lending, strengthen fraud prevention, streamline operations, enhance member experiences, and compete in an increasingly crowded financial landscape. But all of those opportunities require the right tools, resources, and investment flexibility.

Innovation requires capital. Banks and FinTechs are pouring billions into AI, automation, and digital platforms, and credit unions need to be able to invest alongside them and have a seat at the table in shaping these technologies. As Dennis Dollar put it, the cap threatens to put credit unions “behind the AI and FinTech eight ball,” and I would argue it already has.

Stablecoins make the point concrete. Under the GENIUS Act, federally insured credit unions cannot issue payment stablecoins directly. NCUA’s implementing proposal would require issuance through a separately organized credit union subsidiary, or CUSO approved as a licensed payment stablecoin issuer. For a credit union already invested in insurance, business lending, or back-office CUSOs, standing up a stablecoin CUSO could quickly consume whatever room remains under the cap.

This is especially true for smaller credit unions that, by definition, have more limited infrastructure and resources than the big guys. CUSOs play a critical role in leveling the playing field by pooling resources, sharing costs, and mitigating risk as we navigate the brave new world of AI governance, stablecoin implementation, and other emerging technologies.

When credit unions are literally limited in their ability to invest in and participate in new member solutions, our entire credit union movement slows down and innovation lags.

So what’s the solution?

Credit unions deserve modern investment guidelines that offer flexibility based on each institution’s financial condition and investment strategy, rather than a one-size-fits-all 1% cap.

There are a few ways to get there. Dennis Dollar has suggested that if Congress keeps a statutory cap at all, something closer to 10% would be appropriate. Better still would be to remove the arbitrary number from the law entirely, let each credit union set its own CUSO investment policy, and let federal and state regulators monitor the safety and soundness of those policies through the examination and supervisory process. After all, the right level depends on each credit union’s balance sheet, capital position, and risk management capabilities. For some, even 10% may not be enough; for others, 1% may be too much.

Either increasing or eliminating the cap would allow credit unions to participate, as they see fit, in a wider range of CUSO investment opportunities that accelerate industry innovation and technology development.

Of course, CUSO investments should continue to be evaluated carefully. We’re fighting for updated rules, not undisciplined investing. Removing the 1% cap does not mean throwing out good governance and due diligence. Investment decisions would still be made thoughtfully, but with greater flexibility to meet each credit union’s goals.

Where things stand

NACUSO has worked closely with America’s Credit Unions and engaged a Washington-based advocacy firm to coordinate our Capitol Hill outreach. The issue first gained traction during last year’s stablecoin legislation discussions, and state leagues and credit union leaders across the movement have been remarkably collaborative.

The response from Congress has been encouraging. Many offices don’t fully grasp what CUSOs are or how they affect the credit union industry. But once we explain the issue, we haven’t heard arguments that raising the cap would be bad for credit unions, the industry, or members. Instead, we’ve seen real energy from congressional staff and a growing recognition that the 1% cap is arbitrary and overdue for an update.

We’re also being careful. Our goal is a clean fix, not a broader legislative package that attaches new regulatory burdens to credit unions. And for once, this is a chance for our industry to play a little offense instead of defense on Capitol Hill.

The time to act is now

The financial services industry isn’t slowing down, and credit unions can’t afford outdated rules holding them back. Emerging technologies are creating opportunities that require significant investment, and credit unions cannot afford to miss out.

CUSOs give credit unions the ability to pool resources and innovate, but the outdated 1% cap is slowing down our industry and limiting credit unions’ ability to compete.

It’s time to modernize the rules and give credit unions the flexibility to invest in their own success. NACUSO is fighting on Capitol Hill to raise the 1% investment cap, and we need credit unions to join us. Contact us to learn more about how you can help. Make your voice heard, engage with your legislators, and stand with NACUSO in advocating for change.

Together, we can ensure the cooperative model remains a competitive advantage for generations to come.

Author

  • Randy Salser is President and CEO of the National Association of Credit Union Service Organizations (NACUSO), which advocates for the growth, development, and success of CUSOs and the credit union cooperative model. Learn more about NACUSO at https://nacuso.org/.

    View all posts

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *